Mere Christianity Book Review: C.S. Lewis's Timeless Defense of Faith and Reason

Why This 80-Year-Old Book Still Transforms Lives Today

You know those books that change everything? The ones you finish and immediately want to press into a friend's hands saying, "You have to read this"? For millions of readers across generations, Mere Christianity by C.S. Lewis is exactly that kind of book.

Written during World War II as a series of BBC radio talks, Lewis had a simple but ambitious goal: explain the heart of Christian faith in a way that made sense to everyday people—believers wrestling with doubt, seekers asking honest questions, and skeptics willing to listen. Nearly eighty years later, it's still doing exactly that. And honestly? In our current age of information overload and spiritual confusion, we might need Lewis's clear-headed wisdom more than ever.

About the Book and Its Author

C.S. Lewis: From Atheist to Apologist

Here's what I love about C.S. Lewis—he wasn't some ivory tower theologian who'd never questioned God. This man was a hardcore atheist. He thought Christianity was just another mythology, a comforting fairy tale for people who couldn't handle reality. So when he finally came to faith in his early thirties, it wasn't some emotional moment at a revival meeting. He famously described himself as "the most dejected and reluctant convert in all England."

That reluctant journey? It's what makes him such a powerful voice for skeptics and doubters. He's been where you are. He knows the objections because he made them himself. Beyond Mere Christianity, Lewis gave us The Chronicles of Narnia, The Screwtape Letters, and dozens of other works that continue to shape how Christians think and write today.

The Heart of the Message

Think of Mere Christianity as a four-course meal, with each book building on what came before.

The Moral Law — Lewis starts with something we can all relate to: that nagging sense of right and wrong. You know, that feeling when someone cuts in line and you think, "Hey, that's not fair!" Lewis asks: where does that universal sense of fairness come from? And his answer points straight to God.

Christian Behavior — Once we've established there's a moral law (and a moral lawgiver), Lewis gets practical. What does it actually look like to live as a Christian? He walks through the classic virtues—prudence, temperance, justice, fortitude—alongside faith, hope, and charity. No fluff here, just honest talk about what it means to follow Jesus in real life.

The Nature of God — This is where Lewis tackles the big questions: Who is God? What's the deal with the Trinity? Why did Jesus have to become human? I'll be honest—some of this gets a bit heady. But Lewis has this gift for taking complex theology and making it understandable without watering it down.

Faith and Transformation — The book wraps up with what Christianity is really about: becoming new people. Lewis describes it as becoming "little Christs"—and no, that's not blasphemous. It's about letting God transform us from the inside out, which is both terrifying and beautiful.

What makes all of this work is Lewis's voice. He writes like he's sitting across the table from you at a coffee shop, using everyday examples and logical steps that just... click.

The Good: What Makes This Book Extraordinary

Clarity That Crosses Denominational Lines

One of my favorite things about Mere Christianity is that Lewis isn't trying to convince you to become Baptist or Presbyterian or Catholic. He's focused on the core—what he calls "mere" Christianity. The beliefs that unite us across denominations.

He has this brilliant metaphor about Christianity being a hallway with different doors. The hallway is Christianity itself, and the various denominations are just different rooms you can enter. Some of us prefer one room over another, but we're all in the same house. As someone who's worshiped in different traditions over the years, I find this perspective incredibly refreshing and humble.

Memorable Analogies That Stick With You

Lewis understood something crucial: we remember stories and pictures, not abstract concepts. So he fills Mere Christianity with analogies that lodge in your brain.

Like when he compares God to a dentist. Nobody loves going to the dentist, right? We'd all rather avoid that chair. But when you've got a toothache, suddenly that dentist is the person you need most. That's us with God and our moral failures—we'd rather not face the discomfort of change, but deep down we know we desperately need the healing.

Or his explanation of pride as the "great sin." He doesn't just say pride is bad and move on. He shows how pride turns us into competitors with God instead of His children. It's the difference between a toddler insisting "I do it myself!" and falling flat, versus accepting Dad's helping hand. Years after reading this, I still catch myself when pride creeps in and think, "There's Lewis again, being right about me."

A Rational Foundation When You Need One

Let me tell you, there have been seasons in my faith where I needed something solid to stand on. Not just feelings, not just tradition, but reasons. Mere Christianity delivers that in spades.

Lewis doesn't ask you to check your brain at the door. Instead, he shows you how Christianity makes sense—how it actually explains reality better than the alternatives. His famous "Lord, liar, or lunatic" argument about Jesus is one you've probably heard quoted dozens of times, even if you didn't know it came from this book. The logic is simple but powerful: Jesus claimed to be God. Either He was telling the truth, deliberately lying, or completely delusional. There's really no middle ground of "nice moral teacher."

Now, will this book answer every objection you've ever had? Probably not. But it'll give you a framework for thinking through the big questions without feeling like you're betraying your intellect.

It Never Gets Old

I first read Mere Christianity in college, and I've returned to it probably half a dozen times since. What strikes me every time is how current it feels. Sure, Lewis talks about wartime rationing and British social customs that feel a bit foreign. But the core questions? Those haven't changed at all.

What does it mean to be good? How do we make moral choices when everything's complicated? Can people really change, or are we stuck being who we've always been? Whether you're reading this in 1952 or 2025, these are still the questions keeping us up at night.

Does It Hold Up to Scripture?

Here's the question every discerning Christian should ask: Is Lewis biblical?

The encouraging answer is yes—remarkably so for someone who came to faith later in life. When Lewis argues for a universal moral law, he's essentially restating what Paul wrote in Romans 2:14-15: "Indeed, when Gentiles, who do not have the law, do by nature things required by the law... they show that the requirements of the law are written on their hearts."

His discussion of transformation—of becoming "little Christs"—echoes Paul's words in Galatians 2:20: "I have been crucified with Christ and I no longer live, but Christ lives in me." Lewis understood that Christianity isn't about behavior modification; it's about becoming a new creation (2 Corinthians 5:17).

On the Incarnation, Lewis is unflinchingly orthodox. The Second Person of the Trinity actually became human—fully God and fully man (John 1:14). This isn't God pretending or play-acting; it's the shocking claim that the Creator entered His creation as one of us. Lewis shows why this matters: only a perfect God-man could bridge the gap between holy God and sinful humanity.

That said, Lewis occasionally uses language that might raise evangelical eyebrows. His Anglican background sometimes shows through in ways that differ from Reformed or Baptist perspectives. But his core arguments rest on solid biblical ground.

Where Christian Readers Might Push Back

Salvation Could Be Clearer

Lewis intentionally avoids denominational debates about exactly how salvation works—is it faith alone? Faith plus works? Predestination or free will? His ecumenical approach is both a strength and weakness. Readers seeking clarity on justification by faith (Romans 3:28) or the doctrines of grace might find Lewis frustratingly vague.

The "Trilemma" Has Gaps

The famous "liar, lunatic, or Lord" argument is powerful but not bulletproof. Critics note that Lewis doesn't address the possibility that Gospel accounts might be legendary embellishments. While I find this objection weak (scholars like Richard Bauckham and Craig Blomberg have demonstrated the Gospels' early dating and eyewitness connections), it's worth acknowledging.

Some Theological Positions Raise Questions

Lewis's Anglican background occasionally surfaces in ways that might trouble some Protestants—particularly his hints about purgatory and his view that some who "seek God sincerely" might be saved without explicit Christian profession. These aren't major themes in Mere Christianity, but attentive readers will notice them.

The Not-So-Good: A Few More Things to Keep in Mind

Sometimes You'll Need to Slow Down

Look, I'm not going to pretend every page of this book reads like a thriller novel. When Lewis digs into the Trinity or debates the nature of free will, you might find yourself reading the same paragraph three times. I certainly have.

If you're expecting The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe, this isn't that. Mere Christianity asks you to think, to pause, to wrestle with ideas. Some people will love that; others might find it frustrating. Just know going in that this is a book to chew on slowly, not gulp down in one sitting.

The 1940s Are Showing

Lewis was writing for a British audience in the middle of World War II, and sometimes that context feels a bit distant. He makes references to social conventions and wartime realities that might have you going, "Huh?"

But here's the thing: the principles underneath those examples are timeless. You might have to do a tiny bit of mental translation—kind of like when you're reading older Bible translations and you come across "thou" and "thine"—but the core message comes through loud and clear.

It's an Introduction, Not the Encyclopedia

Lewis himself would tell you that Mere Christianity is just the beginning. It's Christianity 101, not a PhD course. If you're looking for deep dives into specific Bible passages or detailed denominational theology, you'll need to supplement this with other books.

Think of it like learning to cook. Mere Christianity teaches you the basics—how to hold a knife, what sautéing means, why you need to preheat the oven. But you'll still need other cookbooks (and lots of practice) to become a chef. Lewis is giving you the foundation; the rest of your faith journey builds on that.

How This Book Will Change Your Walk With God

Reading Mere Christianity isn't just an intellectual exercise. Here's what it actually does:

It Strengthens Your Witness — After reading this, you'll be able to have conversations with skeptical friends without resorting to "just have faith" or "the Bible says so." You'll understand how to build a bridge from common ground (we all sense right and wrong) to ultimate truth (God exists and has revealed Himself).

It Confronts Your Pride — Lewis's chapter on pride is brutal in the best way. You'll find yourself convicted about subtle ways you've been competing with God instead of submitting to Him. This alone is worth the price of admission.

It Clarifies What You Actually Believe — Many Christians hold vague, fuzzy ideas about core doctrines. Lewis forces you to think clearly about the Trinity, the Atonement, and what it actually means to be saved.

Who Should (and Shouldn't) Read This Book

Read this if you're:

• Wrestling with intellectual doubts about Christianity's truthfulness
• Preparing for college or entering an environment hostile to faith
• Wanting to share your faith but feeling tongue-tied when challenged
• A small group leader looking for a solid apologetics resource
• Someone who loves theology but wants it served without unnecessary jargon

Maybe skip this if you're:

• Looking for devotional warmth or emotional encouragement (Lewis is logical, not sentimental)
• Seeking detailed biblical exposition (this is philosophy and apologetics, not verse-by-verse commentary)
• Wanting quick answers in bite-sized form (this requires slow, careful reading)
• Completely new to Christianity and need the Gospel explained simply first

Final Verdict: Still a Game-Changer

Nearly eighty years after publication, Mere Christianity remains one of those rare books that meets you wherever you are. Skeptical? Lewis was too once. Confused about theology? He makes it clearer. Wrestling with whether this whole Christian thing is intellectually defensible? He's got your back.

What I appreciate most about Lewis is his honesty. He doesn't make Christianity sound easy or paint it as some simple self-help program. Following Jesus is demanding. It'll cost you everything. But Lewis also shows you why it's worth it—why transformation is possible, why hope is reasonable, and why the story Christianity tells about the world actually rings true.

Whether you read this book in one weekend or spend months working through it slowly, I'm confident it'll change how you think. It might even change how you live.

Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (5/5) — A modern classic that absolutely deserves a spot on your shelf.

Comments

Login to comment